In short: Gametes and embryos in vitro depend entirely on the laboratory for temperature, pH, oxygen and osmolality. ESHRE good practice asks that temperature, pH and osmolality are kept appropriate, and that fluctuations are minimised. The evidence, though limited, favours culture at 37 °C and low oxygen, while pH targets should follow the medium manufacturer. Osmolality drifts through evaporation, so oil overlay, drop volume and incubator humidity matter. Independent, calibrated monitoring and alarms turn these principles into daily control.
Embryos in vitro face stresses they would not meet in vivo. These include pH and temperature shifts, atmospheric oxygen and toxins building up in static culture (Wale and Gardner, 2016). When more than one stress is present, negative synergies can result. Brief exposures may also have effects after transfer.
The Vienna consensus lists culture conditions (temperature, pH, pO2) and environmental conditions (light, air quality, humidity) among external factors affecting oocyte competence. It names pO2 as a confounder of blastocyst development rates (ESHRE and Alpha, 2017). ESHRE guidance states that oocytes and embryos must always be kept at appropriate temperature, pH and osmolality during culture and handling (ESHRE Guideline Group, 2016).
Human meiotic spindles are very sensitive to cooling. In one study, spindles disassembled within 5 minutes of cooling to room temperature. They recovered within 20 minutes if rewarming to 37 °C started promptly. After 10 minutes held at 33, 28 or 25 °C, spindles recovered in 5/5, 2/5 and 0/5 oocytes respectively (Wang et al., 2001).
Thermal control during ICSI also matters. In one clinic study, not reported as randomised, a thermostated coverslip plus objective heater gave 78.8% fertilisation. This compared with 56.7% for the coverslip alone and 64.0% for a conventional stage warmer (Wang et al., 2002). ESHRE asks for equipment that keeps oocytes close to 37 °C at retrieval, with pre-warmed media, tubes and dishes (ESHRE Guideline Group, 2016).
Dishes cool fast outside the incubator. After 3 minutes without a heated stage or airflow, medium under oil fell below 34 °C. With airflow and no stage it fell below 33 °C. On a heated stage it was still below 36 °C, except in flat ICSI dishes, which stayed close to 37 °C (Korakaki et al., 2020).
Is a cooler incubator better? A paired RCT of sibling oocytes (52 couples) found more usable blastocysts per zygote at 37 °C than 36 °C (48.4% versus 41.2%). Sustained implantation was equivalent (Hong et al., 2014). A Cochrane review of three RCTs (563 women) was uncertain whether temperatures below 37 °C improve outcomes. The evidence was of very low quality (Baak et al., 2019).
The key point is that the display is not the dish. Measure the temperature in a drop under oil, in the dish types you use, on each heated stage and in each incubator position.
Embryos have limited ability to regulate internal pH, and oocytes lack robust mechanisms. Denuded oocytes and warmed embryos are especially vulnerable to pH change (Swain, 2010). In bicarbonate-buffered media, pH depends on the CO2 level, through the bicarbonate buffering system. Altitude and air pressure also influence pH, through effects on CO2 (Bartolacci et al., 2023). A CO2 setting that works at sea level may therefore need adjusting at altitude.
No single optimal pH has been identified. Most commercial media companies recommend ranges within 7.2 to 7.4. Swain advises following manufacturer recommendations and keeping a small acceptable range (Swain, 2012). ESHRE says bicarbonate-buffered media should be kept in 5 to 7% CO2, and HEPES or MOPS-buffered media in air (ESHRE Guideline Group, 2016).
Media differ in bicarbonate content, so the same CO2 setting can give a different pH in another product. Measure pH in medium fully equilibrated in the incubator, and read it before it cools or loses CO2. Use a blood gas analyser or a temperature-compensated pH meter. Never set CO2 from the incubator display alone.
Atmospheric oxygen is about 20%. Some laboratories culture at about 5%, which is closer to levels in the oviduct and uterus (Bontekoe et al., 2012). That Cochrane review included seven RCTs (2,422 participants). Pooled data from four (1,382 participants) showed higher live birth with low oxygen (OR 1.39, 95% CI 1.11 to 1.76). The authors estimated that a 30% live birth rate might rise to between 32% and 43%. Trial quality was relatively low, and adverse events did not increase.
ESHRE states that low oxygen should be used for blastocyst culture (ESHRE Guideline Group, 2016). A 2023 review scored eight studies of biphasic culture (5% then 2%). It found no evidence that this beats 5% throughout, especially for clinical outcomes (Bartolacci et al., 2023).
A commonly cited range for human embryo culture media is 255 to 295 mOsm/kg (Bossi et al., 2023). Check your own medium's specification. In one study, smaller drops and preparation on a 37 °C stage raised osmolality. Combined with airflow, the rise reached about 40 mOsm/kg. Mouse embryo development was impaired above 310 mOsm/kg (Swain et al., 2012).
During culture, incubator humidity, oil volume, medium type and time-lapse dish design all affected evaporation. Media starting at high osmolality were most at risk of becoming hypertonic (Mestres et al., 2021). Dry incubation raised osmolality in single-step and sequential media, while humid incubation kept it stable (Bossi et al., 2023). Over 5 days of dry culture in large drops, high-viscosity oil protected no better than light oil (Murray et al., 2025). Clinical evidence is mixed: a 2023 review scored four studies, and only two favoured humid culture (Bartolacci et al., 2023).
One study found 95% of the light reaching embryos came from microscopes. Ambient light contributed little, so dark laboratories were not considered justified (Ottosen et al., 2007). ESHRE asks that exposure to light is minimised (ESHRE Guideline Group, 2016).
ESHRE recommends HEPA and VOC control of laboratory air, positive pressure, and high-purity gas with inline HEPA and VOC filters. Building materials should minimise VOC release (ESHRE Guideline Group, 2016). The Cairo consensus on air quality sets out more than 50 points on site suitability, design, commissioning and ongoing VOC management (Mortimer et al., 2018).
ESHRE accepts either sequential or single-step media designed for embryo development (ESHRE Guideline Group, 2016). A meta-analysis of four RCTs found no difference in ongoing pregnancy between the two approaches (RR 1.11, 95% CI 0.87 to 1.40) (Dieamant et al., 2017). The 2026 Cochrane update found insufficient evidence to support or refute any specific culture medium (Laverde et al., 2026).
Smaller benchtop or top-load incubators recover temperature and gas faster than large box incubators. No type has a clear advantage on clinical outcomes, and management and workload matter for any design (Swain, 2014). ESHRE asks that incubator numbers match cycles and culture duration, with embryos spread to minimise door openings (ESHRE Guideline Group, 2016).
ESHRE requires equipment performance to be verified with calibrated instruments. Accepted ranges should be set for every measured parameter, and corrections verified. Incubators should be continuously monitored with alarms and have automatic backup power (ESHRE Guideline Group, 2016).
The Vienna consensus recommends collecting indicator data ideally monthly. It describes blastocyst development rate as reflecting the efficiency of the whole culture system (ESHRE and Alpha, 2017). A fall in development KPIs should prompt a review of IQC logs.
| Parameter | Guidance or value | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Temperature during handling | Keep oocytes close to 37 °C; pre-warm media and dishes | ESHRE 2015 guideline |
| Culture temperature below 37 °C | Uncertain benefit (3 RCTs); very low quality evidence | Cochrane 2019 |
| Bicarbonate-buffered media | 5 to 7% CO2 | ESHRE 2015 guideline |
| HEPES or MOPS-buffered media | Atmospheric air | ESHRE 2015 guideline |
| Medium pH | Follow manufacturer; most ranges within 7.2 to 7.4 | Swain 2012 |
| Oxygen | Low oxygen for blastocyst culture | ESHRE 2015 guideline |
| Low (about 5%) versus about 20% oxygen | Live birth OR 1.39 (95% CI 1.11 to 1.76; 4 RCTs, 1,382 participants) | Cochrane 2012 |
| Medium osmolality | Commonly cited range 255 to 295 mOsm/kg; check product specification | Bossi et al. 2023 |
| Oil overlay | Minimises changes in temperature, pH and osmolality | ESHRE 2015 guideline |
| Light | Minimise exposure; microscopes are the main source | ESHRE 2015; Ottosen 2007 |
| Air quality | HEPA and VOC control; positive pressure | ESHRE 2015 guideline |
| Critical equipment | Continuous monitoring, alarms, backup power | ESHRE 2015 guideline |
| Single-step versus sequential | No difference in ongoing pregnancy (4 RCTs) | Dieamant 2017 |
| KPI data collection | Ideally monthly | Vienna 2017 |
IVF.net education pages are written from the published sources listed above and reviewed before publication. Last reviewed: October 2026. If you spot an error, please let us know.